Comments:
The exact lineage of Kung Fu San Soo is extremely difficult to
trace. It may in fact be impossible. This study therefore is
a work in progress and given new information, it may change.
This lineage also uses the Romanized Cantonese
spelling 'Chan',
which is more popular among the Southern Chinese artists, and
substituted for the Mandarin 'Chen', and the Hoisanese
'Chin'.
Lineage assertions fall into two distinct camps: the
official International Kung Fu San Soo Association
view held by those who believe they firmly understand the lineage
left by the late Grandmaster Chan Siu Dek (Jimmy H. Woo); and
those that have clear and undisputable documentation and testimony
placing Chan Siu Hung (Cantonese,
Chen Shiu Xiong in Mandarin),
Chan Siu Dek's great uncle and universally acknowledged teacher,
in the accepted historical lineage of the very popular Nánquán
art of Choy
Li Fut.
There are many historic Choy Li Fut practitioners around the world
today. Chan
Yong Fa and Ng
Fu Hang are two who offer significant interest to Kung Fu San
Soo practitioners, as they are the living great, great grandsons
of Chan Heung, the founder of Choy Li Fut,
and share the Chan surname. Some Kung Fu San Soo researchers hold
them to technically be 'adoptive' step cousins of Chan
Siu Dek himself.
This study chooses to accept the rather unorthodox conclusion that
both lineages are correct. We accept the Choy Li Fut
lineage as documentable through numerous sources, many included
here, although we do not claim that Kung Fu San Soo is a formally
descended Choy Li Fut art, or a member of the formal Choy Li Fut
lineages. We only allow that it clearly has roots closely associated in
its background. And we also accept the official International Kung
Fu San Soo association lineage as the personal family lineage
left by Chan Siu Dek, as well as anyone could understand it, because
we thoroughly trust the intentions and integrity of the late Grandmaster,
Losifu Chan Siu Dek.
However, after contacting numerous individuals close to both sides
of the issue, no one has been able to provide us with historical
evidence showing us exactly who Chan Siu Don or Leoung
Kick actually were. From our experience, one can Google
just about any Romanized spelling possible and the only place
any reference shows up is on Kung Fu San Soo web sites. And
so far, we know of no one who fluent in Chinese that has been
interested enough to use the Chinese search engines to try and
find some reference that would put flesh on these bones.
So we've drawn our own conclusion. While Leoung Kick and
Chin Moon Don could possibly be other names for Chan
Yuen Woo or Choi Fuk, and Chan Koon Pak respectively,
it's presently our opinion that they were probably real members
of Chan Siu Dek's family ancestry, share a parallel lineage, and
favored by Chan Siu Dek himself when viewing his own lineage.
Interestingly, if we take seriously the recent testimony of
Chan Sai Mo (Cantonese,
Chin Shi Wu Mandarin),
the cousin of Chan Siu Dek and son of Chan Siu Hung,
as reported
from China, and from the calligraphy left behind by Chan
Siu Dek, we have his claim that Chan Heung and Chin
Moon Don were the same person remembered by different
names. It's on the basis of his testimony that we tie in the
two lineages at this point. Rather than offering a contradiction,
we see this as lending significant support the 'official'
accepted lineage left to us by Chan Siu Dek himself.
We only wish we had more evidence to offer students of the
lineage with respect to the undocumented individuals and the
official lineage. Still, we attempt to document this tree through
the following sources.
Pre Buddhist Wushu
Chinese martial history prior to the introduction to Buddhism.
This would include Confucian and Taoist backgrounds. More
about pre-Buddhist Wushu.
back to tree
Bodhidarma
Legendary
monk said to have brought Buddhism into the Chinese Taoist
and Confucian systems, forging a synthesis between pre-Buddhist
wushu and Buddhist health and body building practices.
back to tree
Taoist Influences
We believe that Kung Fu San Soo contains elements of the Chángquán,
or northern styles, especially Taoist Wudangguan,
and particularly in the free sparring method of training. The Taoist
influence is sometimes attributed to or associated with the famous
Taoist temples of the Wudang Mountains, at least in folklore.
The most famous of the Taoist styles might be Taijiquan.
This is not actually a part of the simplified official International
Kung Fu San Soo Association lineage, and not a part of official
Choy Li Fut lineage, but we place it here in attempt to
explain certain highly probably influences.
back to tree
Shaolin Temples
The famous Temple
System of Shaolin Wushu (Mandarin,
Sil Lum Wusu in Cantonese).
The most notable were the earlier Northern Temple at
Henan, and the Southern Temple at Fujian. More
about the temples in the history of Kung Fu San Soo.
back to tree
Medieval Modifications
Gok Yuen, Lee Sau, Ba Yee Fang, three Medieval Shaolin monks which
legend holds to be attributed for the modification and improvement
of the institutionalized wushu arts.
back to tree
Long Fist and Red Fist Influence
We're speculating here, but there's a strong possibility that in
its pre-Nánquán lineage, before the fall of the
Ming Dynasty, Kung Fu San Soo inherited some aspects of the
longer Chángquán
(Beiquan) styles. This influence would likely include Tàizû
Longfist, or First Emperor Kung Fu, and possibly Redfist,
or Hóngquán. Again, this is not actually
a part of the simplified official International Kung Fu
San Soo Association lineage, and not a part of the official
Choy Li Fut lineage, but we place it here in attempt
to explain certain highly probably influences.
back to tree
Five Families
Five Families of the Southern martial styles. More
about the Five Families of Kung Fu San Soo.
back to tree
Lin Quan Yuan Temple
The famous Southern Temple of Lin
Quan Yuan, the highly probably place of psychological and physiological
refinement for the reactive fundamental fighting aspects that would
one day become embodied in many of the Nánquán fighting
arts, and of special interest to us, the art of Kung Fu San
Soo.
back to tree
Flower Fist Influence
Some of the most knowledgeable first generation practitioners
have expressed strong conviction that Chan Siu Dek first taught
a simplified standup version of a longer style which was most
likely "Flower Fist" Chángquán,
or Huãquán.
It is historically likely to have been a longer influence toward
the Lin Quan Yuan transformation to the Nánquán,
or Southern fist styles, at the end of the Ming and the early
Qing Dynasties. This simple long style is sometimes referred
to as "Old San Soo" in the American lineage and dates
to the beginning of the El Monte school. As a longer method,
it may possibly also serve to help distinguish Kung Fu San Soo
from other shorter method Nánquán arts that share
a similar background, arts like Wing Chun. Once again,
this is not actually a part of the simplified official International
Kung Fu San Soo Association lineage, and not a part of
official Choy Li Fut lineage, but we place it here
in attempt to explain certain highly probably influences.
back to tree
Chan Heung's Teachers
Chan
Yuen Woo, Li
Yau San, and Choi
Fuk, the three teachers of the founder of Choy Li Fut,
Chan Heung. Through the Hero's Victory lineage of Choy
Li Fut, we can trace the lineage of Chan Siu Dek's great uncle,
Chan Siu Hung.
back to tree
Leoung Kick
Held to be an ancestor of Chan Siu Dek, and as oral history goes,
the person who left the temple system with the books Chan Siu Dek
used in his teachings. He would probably have been one generation
earlier than Chan Heung, and as a monk from the monastery
at Pong Hong, part of the larger temple system which included Chan
Heung's teachers. Some seem to think he could be the same person
as Chan Yuen Woo, others suggest the Monk, Choi Fuk.
David Lorenson holds the former opinion, and given the extent of his research, it's very possible he's correct.
The latter is a most interesting possibility, as both were reported
to have been monks surviving the destruction of the temples,
and both lived about the same time period. But while those are
two distinct possibilities, and as much as we would love to
have some proof, no one was able or willing to offer us evidence
of either. So we list him here as a distinct individual. We'd
love to have something more, but unfortunately, no one provided
us with any tangible reference or documentation regarding this
person. More
about the story of Leoung Kick and the temples.
back to tree
Chan Heung
Chan Heung in Cantonese,
Chen Xiong in Mandarin.
Chan
Heung is popularly held to be the founder of internationally
recognized art of Choy
Li Fut, an art that shares three of the same calligraphic
characters with Choy Li Ho Fut Hung, and a person critical to
the history and lineage of Kung Fu San Soo. Recent testimony
by Chan Siu Dek's cousin in China, Chan Sai Mo (Cantonese,
Chin Shi Wu in Mandarin),
holds that Chan Heung and Chin Moon Don were
the same person known by different names. There are many historic
reasons why individuals used different names during this
period. Even more important to the student of Kung Fu San Soo
history, is that several individuals claim they remember Chan
Siu Dek proudly pointing to pictures of Chan Heung as his great
grandfather. The official Choy Li Fut lineage shows no record
of this assertion, but recent
evidence suggests that Chan Siu Dek's great uncle, Chan
Siu Hung, may have been adopted by Chan Heung, thereby
lending some legitimacy to Chan Siu Dek's assertion.
back to tree
Chan Koon Pak
Son of Chan Heung, and a definite teacher of Chan
Siu Hung, as documented
by Chan Yiu Chi, grandson of Chan Heung.
back to tree
Chan Siu Don
If the official International Kung Fu San Soo lineage interpretation
is correct, this would be a person in Chan Siu Dek's personal family
lineage that would have roughly been a contemporary of Chan
Koon Pak. So we place these two side by side. Some seem to
think he could be the same person as Chan Koon Pak, including David Lorenson, and
while it's possible, we found no evidence of that. We're very loosely
concluding that this is Chan Siu Dek's paternal grandfather, brother
to his great uncle, Chan Siu Hung, and therefore one of
the stepsons of Chan Heung.
But there are some significant difficulties. Some credible sources
hold that family records indicate that Chan Siu Dek's paternal
grandfather was Chin Wen Zan. Whether Chin Wen
Zan and Chan Siu Don were different names for
the same person or different individuals, we cannot say. It
does present a conflict. We'd love to have something more, but
unfortunately, no one has been able to provide us with any tangible
documentation regarding this person, or the relationship between
him, Chan Heung, and Chan Siu Dek. And while we can't
say we've left no stone unturned with respect to information,
because we are extremely reluctant to trouble family members,
we will say that we've done our share of begging from many other
known sources.
It is highly possible that David Lorenson is correct, but that this person is a member of Chan Siu Dek's extended "Kung Fu Family", perhaps a Chan cousin, rather than a direct paternal ancestor, which is by the way, a perfectly respectable, sincere, and honest way for a Chinese martial practitioner to describe his own personal lineage, although somewhat beyond the scope of the cultural divide between East and West .
back to tree
Chan Siu Hung
Chan Siu Hung in Cantonese,
Chen Shiu Xiong in Mandarin.
Chan Siu Dek's great uncle, and most notable teacher. Chan
Siu Hung was definitely trained in the Choy Li Fut as documented
by Chan Yiu Chi, grandson of Chan Heung, and
as noted in the Official Choy Li Fut lineage study of the Li
Iu Ling Martial Arts Alumni Association. Search down the
page from this last link for Chan Siu Hung, and you'll
find it in Table 2, under Chan Koon Pak, in the Hung
Sing Hero's Victory Lineage. Interestingly, the Hung
Sing Choy Li Fut branch in San Francisco was rumored to
be a place where the late Chan Siu Dek practiced when he visited
the famous Choy Li Fut great-Grandmaster, Lau
Bun. It's also one of the few places where we found the
calligraphic character Chan Siu Dek used for 'Ho" in Choy
Li Ho Fut Hung. We discuss this somewhat further here.
back to tree
Chan Sai Mo
Chan Sai Mo is the son of Chan
Siu Hung and a cousin of Chan Siu Dek. He was known to
be alive as late as 2005, but well into his nineties. He was recently
interviewed
by both Kung Fu San Soo students, and highly respected Choy Li Fut
practitioner, Chan Yuk, or Paul Chan.
back to tree
Chan Siu Dek
The late Grandmaster and founder of Kung Fu San Soo, or American
Choi Li Ho Fut Hung, honored
here in great company by his Chinese home community of Taishan.
Although he was trained in Choy Li Fut through his great uncle,
Chan Siu Hung, he either brought to American a slightly
different art, or created a new art altogether, breaking from the
official Choy Li Fut traditions at this point in the lineage tree.
It's difficult at this time to determine which. He went by the name
of Jimmy H. Woo, but his given name was Chan
Siu Dek, (Chen Shou Jue in Mandarin,
Zhen She De in Pinyin,
Chin Siu Dek in Hoisanese).
More about Chan
Siu Dek.
back to tree
Paul Chan
We include Choy Li Fut Master, Paul
Chan (Chan Yuk), because he includes and honors both Chan
Sai Mo (Cantonese,
Chin Shi Wu in Mandarin),
and Chan Sai Mo's father, Chan Siu Hung, in his own lineage,
and has provided Kung Fu San Soo history students with information
and testimony from interviews with Chan Sai Mo about
both Chan Siu Dek from the time they studied together in Sanba
Town, Taishan City, Guandong Province, China, and about Chan
Sai Mo's father, Chan Siu Hung. Through his own research,
in his own lineage, Paul Chan holds Chan Siu Dek's great uncle,
Chan Siu Hung, was the stepson of Choy Li Fut founder, Chan
Heung. If this is correct, then through this family family
link, this places Chan Siu Dek right at the core of one of the
most notable of all the Nánquán martial arts, just
as he claimed. It also serves as a significant source of pride
for all Kung Fu San Soo practitioners.
back to tree
Chan Tai Shan
We include the late Chan
Tai Shan because he was:
- A practitioner who included Chan Siu Hung's son, Chan Sai
Mo, and cousin to Chan Siu Dek, in his own training lineage
- A tough American practitioner who taught in New York City
Chinatown
- Held by Chinese martial arts historians and the Chinese government,
and noted in Inside Kung Fu Magazine, to be one of China's
"National Treasures"
Nothing would thrill us more than to see Losifu Chan Siu Dek
one day also honored in this way, serving to further legitimize
his family art, our art, Kung Fu San Soo.
back to tree
Bill Lasiter
Bill Lasiter
is a first generation master under Chan Siu Dek, a Grandmaster today,
and although we acknowledge some controversy surrounding the title,
we simply accept it in good faith and move on in the art. Through
him we trace the lineage of the Sonora School of Kung Fu San Soo.
back to tree
Rusty Wallace
Rusty Wallace, founder of the Sonora School of Kung Fu San
Soo. Rusty studied with Bill Lasiter from 1974 until 1991, and
received his Master's degree in 1986. He's produced three more
masters, a score of black belts, and continues to teach at the
school located
in Sonora, California.
back to tree
Anthony Shaw, Joe Casteel, Don Williams
Masters Anthony Shaw, Joe Casteel, and Don Williams are the first
three third generation masters emerging from the Sonora School.
Tony Shaw shares the Sonora School with Rusty Wallace, teaching
his own group of students. Joe Casteel teaches and continue to study
at the school. Don Williams moved to Florida in 2005 and founded
his own Kung Fu San Soo School.
back to tree
|